July 22, 2011, Philippine Football Federation (PFF) received a letter from the Asian Football Confederation (AFC) informing them of the decision of the International Football Federation (FIFA) on the PFF’s appeal to lift the suspension of two of Philippine National Football Team players, Midfielder Stephan Shrock and, Defender and Team Captain Alexander Borromeo.
The concerned players were both given a yellow card on each leg of their first round match-up against Sri Lanka that resulted on an automatic suspension on their next match. The PFF’s appeal to lift the suspension was in connection to an article in the FIFA Disciplinary Code (FDC), specifically Article 37, paragraph 1, which goes:
Article 37 Cancellation of cautions
1. Upon its own initiative or at the request of a confederation, the Disciplinary Committee may cancel cautions that have not resulted in an expulsion so as to restore the balance among several teams that have not played the same number of matches during the ?rst round of a competition, or in other exceptional circumstances.
The PFF sent an appeal directly to FIFA, just days after the Philippines defeated Sri Lanka, after confirming that the two players will miss the first leg match against Kuwait for the second round of qualifiers, FIFA replied that they need an endorsement from the AFC for them to act on the appeal. As soon as the reply from FIFA, PFF then requested an endorsement from the AFC on the said appeal.
For the decision, FIFA denied the appeal of the PFF according to a letter sent by Alex Soosay, AFC General Secretary, addressed to Ramon Manuel, PFF General Secretary.
—-
Here’s my take on the appeal of the PFF to lift the suspension of Shrock and Borromeo.
Considering the above mentioned Article from the FDC, the PFF has a point and were right on trying to ask FIFA to lift the suspension since:
- The Philippines played on the first round of the qualifiers while Kuwait was seeded and was already waiting for their opponents on the second round, putting Kuwait at an advantage.
- There was no “expulsion”, in my understanding this is a sending off of a player, of the concerned players during the matches. Both players received a yellow card on different matches, thus they were only booked and an automatic suspension given on their next match.
It bothers me that FIFA denied the appeal of the PFF, first and foremost with regards to my second point, Article 37.1 will only be valid if there are no “expulsion” (sending off), meaning if the player concerned is not given a red card on their last match (A player who is slapped with a red card, is automatically suspended on their next match). Shrock and Borromeo were only given yellow cards (booking/caution) on two separate matches meriting them an automatic suspension which will now be in accordance to Article 37.1. Well unless there are other ways a player will be expelled on a match, which I doubt though.
What gives with FIFA’s decision?
With this two points confirms the validity of the appeal of the PFF and in my opinion the FIFA should have been on the side of the PFF in the name of Fair Play.